Darker Sides of Mahatma Gandhi: Ugly Truth of Gandhi

Table of contents

• Introduction
• Chapter 1: The Early Years
• Chapter 2: Gandhi and Women
• Chapter 3: Gandhi’s Attitude Towards Caste
• Chapter 4: Political Manipulations
• Chapter 5: Gandhi and Violence
• Conclusion

Introduction

Mahatma Gandhi, the Father of the Indian Nation, is celebrated worldwide for his principles of non-violence, civil disobedience, and his pivotal role in India’s struggle for independence. His teachings continue to inspire countless individuals and movements across the globe. However, like all historical figures, Gandhi was a complex and multifaceted personality, and his life was not without its controversies and contradictions. In this book, we delve into the lesser-known, darker sides of Mahatma Gandhi, shedding light on aspects of his life and philosophy that challenge the popular narrative.

Chapter 1: The Early Years

The journey of Mahatma Gandhi begins in a manner far different from the image of the revered leader we have come to know. This chapter delves into the formative years of Gandhi’s life, highlighting the darker aspects that have often been overshadowed by his later achievements.

Gandhi’s Racist Views

In the late 19th century, Gandhi embarked on a legal career in South Africa, where he was exposed to the harsh realities of racial discrimination. While Gandhi would later become a champion of civil rights and equality, his early writings and actions in South Africa reveal a deeply troubling side. He often held prejudiced views against black South Africans, referring to them using derogatory terms. Gandhi’s belief in the inherent superiority of Indians over Africans and his advocacy for segregated facilities for different racial groups are difficult to reconcile with his later commitment to non-violence and social justice.

Experiments with Diet and Sexuality

Gandhi’s early years in South Africa also marked the beginning of his experiments with diet and sexuality in the pursuit of spiritual purity. He adopted a vegetarian diet and later embraced fruitarianism, sometimes at the expense of his own health. Gandhi’s unusual dietary practices were driven by his belief in self-control and asceticism as paths to spiritual enlightenment. Additionally, he initiated experiments with celibacy or “Brahmacharya,” which involved sleeping naked with young women, including his own grandnieces, as a test of his self-control. These controversial experiments have since been widely criticized and continue to raise ethical questions about his methods.

The early years of Gandhi’s life provide a complex and somewhat contradictory backdrop to his later activism. While he would go on to become an icon of peace and non-violence, his early experiences and beliefs reveal a side of him that challenges our understanding of his character. As we move forward in this exploration, it is essential to recognize that Gandhi’s journey, like any other, was marked by personal growth, evolution, and the resolution of these early contradictions.

Chapter 2: Gandhi and Women

While Mahatma Gandhi is often celebrated as a champion of women’s rights and equality, a closer examination of his relationships and beliefs reveals a more complex and, at times, problematic perspective on gender.

Relationship with His Wife

Gandhi’s relationship with his wife, Kasturba Gandhi, offers insights into the complexities of his personal life. On one hand, Gandhi publicly praised Kasturba and spoke of her as his “conscience keeper.” However, their marriage was not devoid of difficulties. Gandhi’s commitment to celibacy and strict vegetarianism often placed a significant burden on Kasturba. She was expected to adhere to these principles even when they negatively affected her health. This raises questions about the power dynamics within their marriage and whether Kasturba’s sacrifices were truly voluntary.

Controversial “Brahmacharya” Experiments

Gandhi’s experiments with celibacy, known as “Brahmacharya,” further complicate his relationship with women. As part of his quest for spiritual purity, Gandhi conducted a series of experiments that involved sharing his bed with young women, including his grandnieces. These experiments were intended to test his self-control and willpower. While Gandhi maintained that there was no sexual element to these experiments, they have been widely criticized for their inherently inappropriate nature and the discomfort they caused to the women involved.

It is essential to acknowledge Gandhi’s efforts to advocate for women’s rights and their participation in the Indian independence movement. However, his personal relationships and the controversial “Brahmacharya” experiments demonstrate that his views on women were complex and, at times, inconsistent with his public image as a feminist.

This chapter underscores the importance of examining historical figures with a critical lens, recognizing that even those who champion noble causes may have aspects of their lives that challenge our understanding of their legacy. Gandhi’s views and actions regarding women provide valuable lessons on the complexities of human nature and the need for a more nuanced perspective on historical figures.

Chapter 3: Gandhi’s Attitude Towards Caste

Mahatma Gandhi’s approach to the caste system in India was marked by both advocacy for social reform and some ambivalence, raising questions about the depth of his commitment to eradicating this deeply entrenched social hierarchy.

Caste and Untouchability

Gandhi’s early years in South Africa exposed him to racial discrimination, but it wasn’t until he returned to India that he confronted the harsh realities of the caste system and untouchability. He advocated for the upliftment of the Dalits (formerly known as untouchables) and termed them “Harijans,” meaning “Children of God,” in an attempt to promote their dignity. Gandhi’s efforts to eradicate untouchability were undoubtedly a step in the right direction, and they brought the issue to the forefront of the Indian independence movement.

Ambiguities in His Views

However, Gandhi’s approach to caste was not without its contradictions and complexities. While he spoke against untouchability and worked towards its eradication, he also believed that the caste system could be reformed rather than entirely abolished. He opposed the idea of inter-caste marriages, arguing that such unions would not solve the problem of caste discrimination but rather exacerbate it. Gandhi’s emphasis on maintaining the purity of one’s caste and his willingness to negotiate with orthodox Hindu leaders raised questions about the sincerity of his commitment to challenging the caste system at its core.

Gandhi’s approach to caste, while undoubtedly influential in creating awareness about untouchability, leaves room for critical evaluation. His ambivalence towards inter-caste marriages and his belief in the reformability of the caste system reveal a more complex stance on this deeply ingrained social issue.

This chapter highlights the importance of acknowledging the nuanced aspects of historical figures’ beliefs and actions. Gandhi’s role in the fight against untouchability was significant, but it is essential to recognize that his views on caste were not without their ambiguities and contradictions.

Chapter 4: Political Manipulations

Mahatma Gandhi, known for his commitment to non-violence and moral principles, also engaged in political manipulations and tactical maneuvers during his leadership in the Indian independence movement. This chapter explores some of the instances where Gandhi’s political strategies appeared to diverge from his image as a steadfast advocate of non-violence.

Tactical Alliances

Throughout his political career, Gandhi formed strategic alliances and partnerships to advance the cause of Indian independence. One such alliance was with the Indian National Congress (INC), the leading political party in the independence movement. Gandhi’s association with the INC provided him with a platform to mobilize the masses and push for political reforms. However, this partnership also involved political compromises and maneuvering that aimed to appease various factions within the party.

Role in the Khilafat Movement

One of the most controversial aspects of Gandhi’s political career was his involvement in the Khilafat Movement. This movement, which aimed to protect the rights of the Ottoman Caliph after World War I, saw Gandhi supporting the Khilafat leaders, including those who held conservative and religiously fundamentalist views. Gandhi’s alignment with these leaders raised concerns about his willingness to compromise on his principles to gain support for the Indian independence movement.

Gandhi’s political maneuvers, such as supporting the Khilafat Movement and making concessions to various factions within the INC, have been criticized for their pragmatism and the compromises they entailed. While these actions were driven by his desire to advance the cause of Indian independence, they also raise questions about the extent to which he was willing to compromise on his principles for political gain.

This chapter serves as a reminder that even iconic figures like Gandhi engaged in political strategies that may appear at odds with their public image. It underscores the complexities of leadership in the context of a struggle for independence and the difficult choices that leaders must sometimes make to achieve their goals.

Chapter 5: Gandhi and Violence

Mahatma Gandhi is widely celebrated for his unwavering commitment to non-violence as a means of achieving social and political change. However, there are instances in his life where his stance on violence appears inconsistent and raises questions about his approach in certain situations.

Support for World War I

One notable instance where Gandhi’s commitment to non-violence was challenged was during World War I. While he is remembered for his pacifist principles, Gandhi initially expressed support for the British Empire’s participation in the war. He believed that by participating, India would gain recognition and concessions from the British, which could pave the way for greater autonomy. This support for a war, which involved significant violence and loss of life, seems contradictory to his overarching philosophy of non-violence.

Handling of Communal Riots

Another contentious issue is Gandhi’s approach to communal violence during the lead-up to India’s independence. Despite his calls for Hindu-Muslim unity and his efforts to quell communal tensions, there were instances when he struggled to prevent or control outbreaks of violence. Critics argue that his inability to prevent these riots reflects a limitation in his ability to maintain non-violence in the face of intense communal strife.

Gandhi’s support for World War I and his challenges in preventing communal violence underscore the complexities of applying non-violence in real-world political situations. While he remains an icon of non-violence and civil disobedience, these instances remind us that even the most steadfast proponents of peace may face dilemmas and practical challenges when seeking to uphold their principles in complex, conflict-ridden contexts.

This chapter serves as a reminder that Gandhi, like all historical figures, had moments in his life where his stance on violence appeared inconsistent with his overarching philosophy, shedding light on the complexities of applying non-violence in the face of real-world challenges.

Conclusion

The life and legacy of Mahatma Gandhi are characterized by remarkable achievements in the struggle for India’s independence and his enduring influence as a proponent of non-violence, civil disobedience, and social justice. However, this exploration of the darker sides of Gandhi’s life reveals that even iconic figures possess complexities and contradictions that challenge our understanding of their character and contributions.

Gandhi’s early years in South Africa exposed him to racism and led to the expression of prejudiced views towards black South Africans. His experiments with diet and celibacy, aimed at spiritual purity, have raised ethical questions about the extremes to which he was willing to go in pursuit of his ideals.

In his relationships with women, including his wife Kasturba, Gandhi’s public praise for women’s rights contrasted with the sacrifices expected of them in the name of his principles. His controversial “Brahmacharya” experiments with young women have been widely criticized.

Gandhi’s approach to the caste system in India, while advocating for the upliftment of Dalits and untouchables, also revealed an ambivalence towards the complete eradication of the caste system. His opposition to inter-caste marriages and belief in the reformability of the system raised questions about the depth of his commitment to challenging caste hierarchies.

In the political arena, Gandhi engaged in tactical alliances and compromises to advance the cause of Indian independence. His support for the Khilafat Movement and initial endorsement of World War I, despite his commitment to non-violence, underscore the challenges of navigating the complex political landscape of his time.

Lastly, Gandhi’s handling of communal violence in the lead-up to India’s independence revealed limitations in preventing outbreaks of violence, highlighting the difficulties of maintaining non-violence in the face of intense communal strife.

In conclusion, Mahatma Gandhi’s legacy remains significant, not in spite of these darker sides but because of them. They compel us to engage with historical figures in a nuanced manner, recognizing that human beings are inherently complex. Gandhi’s life and philosophy offer valuable lessons on the complexities of leadership, the challenges of applying non-violence in real-world situations, and the need for critical evaluation even of revered figures. His legacy invites us to embrace a more holistic understanding of the man behind the Mahatma, acknowledging both his admirable principles and the aspects that challenge our perceptions.

ALSO READ ABOUT: Maulana Abul Kalam Azad: A Visionary Leader